The WeWork Aftershock: What a 97% Stock Plunge Signals

16 August, 2023 / Bobby Samuels

Once the shining star of the startup universe, WeWork now faces a stark reversal of fortune. A devastating 97% nosedive in stock value since its 2021 listing and CEO Sandeep Mathrani’s unexpected exit have left the once trailblazing coworking office space provider on treacherously thin ice.

WeWork’s trajectory has shifted dramatically. From once standing as New York City’s largest commercial office tenant to now facing potential NYSE delisting, the company’s situation has devolved from a promising dream to a stark reality. The critical question is, what’s next for WeWork, and how will this impact the NYC commercial real estate market and its different players?

The Rise and Fall of WeWork

A promising beginning turned into a turbulent journey for WeWork. Let’s trace its path from idea to explosive growth to its current status, mired in financial uncertainty.

From Startup to Real Estate Titan

Born from a simple concept, WeWork co-founders Adam Neumann and Miguel McKelvey sought to revolutionize traditional office spaces and become the face of coworking. WeWork began its journey in 2010, with its growth exploding at an unprecedented rate. By 2018, the company had achieved a monumental feat, becoming the most prominent commercial office space tenant in New York City, amassing more than 5.2 million square feet of space. Investors, employees, and the public watched in awe as WeWork continued its unstoppable march.

Cracks in the Foundation: The Failed WeWork IPO

There was a time when WeWork’s CEO, Adam Neumann, drew in the masses with his Elon Musk-like charisma. He orchestrated a remarkable expansion of WeWork, inspiring countless supporters and followers. Yet, the shimmering facade concealed numerous fractures gradually forming beneath the surface.

Despite the company’s bravado, it had a deeply flawed business model. Expensive, long-term lease agreements stood in stark contrast to declining occupancy rates and dwindling average revenue per member. However, the watershed moment revealing these lurking issues was the company’s unsuccessful IPO attempt in 2019.

When WeWork filed its S-1 registration documents, it prompted thorough scrutiny of its financial health and corporate practices. Digging into the details, investors, analysts, and reporters encountered a host of warning signals. WeWork’s 2019 IPO prospectus exposed staggering losses—$1.9 billion in 2018 and a further $904 million in the first half of 2019. Their once-lauded growth strategy was now shrouded in skepticism, with the disconnect between exorbitant expenses and meager revenues becoming glaringly evident. Given the excessive expenditure on advertising, marketing, and lavish amenities, the narrow margins did little to assuage concerns.

Neumann’s Departure and Aftermath

Adam Neumann, despite his charisma, wasn’t immune to critique. His leadership style, rife with unconventional practices, triggered a significant backlash. Mounting concerns over his unchecked authority and questionable ethics led to his departure, significantly impacting WeWork’s trajectory.

The unsuccessful IPO cast a harsh light on WeWork’s realities. Its once coveted valuation plummeted, presenting SoftBank, its primary backer, with a complex predicament. This fallout served as a wake-up call. It underlined the perils of over-ambitious expansion and flawed governance.

After Neumann’s exit, co-CEOs Sebastian Gunningham and Artie Minson briefly steered the ship. Yet, the landscape truly shifted with Sandeep Mathrani’s appointment as CEO in February 2020. His entry marked a new era for WeWork, one of anticipated profitability and steady recovery. Or so he promised.

WeWork’s 97% Stock Plunge: The Cause and Current Landscape

The tale of WeWork’s 97% stock plunge is like a movie script where high hopes meet an unforeseen twist. Unraveling this narrative demands a deeper look at many factors, starting with investor skepticism and ending with the dire current landscape.

The SPAC Listing

With Mathrani at the helm, WeWork dusted off its IPO debacle and went public via a Special Purpose Acquisition Company (SPAC) on October 21, 2021. Although this strategic move granted WeWork a reprieve, it also marked the beginning of more challenging times. It served as a clear warning to investors about the risks of an excessive focus on revenue growth while sidelining profitability for future consideration.

2022: WeWork’s Year of Financial Turmoil

Mathrani’s reign, despite his ambitious promises, entailed a grueling fight against a financial downturn. WeWork’s stock began its relentless plunge from the outset, caught in an unforgiving downward spiral. The close of 2022 saw the company unmistakably entrenched in a crisis. The credit rating agency Fitch underscored the initial struggles by downgrading WeWork’s credit score from a shaky CCC+ to a default-prone CCC, a powerful symbol of the company’s predicament.

WeWork’s woes were not limited to credit downgrades. By 2022’s end, the company’s cash reserves dwindled to a troubling $300 million, a mere third of the previous year’s cushion. This fiscal contraction was particularly alarming given WeWork’s 2021 operational costs of $4.4 billion, vastly overshadowing the $2.7 billion in revenue earned that year. The company’s expense-to-revenue ratio had crept precariously close to 2:1.

Strained investor relations further exacerbated WeWork’s precarious financial position.

Its primary investor, SoftBank, faced a dilemma with WeWork’s consistent net losses, burdensome long-term leases, and evaporating cash flows. Considering that WeWork had already burned through more than $10 billion of SoftBank’s capital, the prospects of further financial support seemed dim, further intensifying the looming threat of Chapter 11 for WeWork.

A Glimmer of Hope in 2023, Quashed

The dawn of 2023 brought glimmers of hope for WeWork. Reduced costs, increased revenue across all sectors, and new product launches indicated a potential resurgence. The company recorded an 11% revenue increase to $849 million in Q1, slashing the net loss to $299 million – a significant YoY improvement of $205 million. The company also saw debt restructuring, new funding, and over $1 billion in capital commitments.

Yet, despite this promising trajectory, the share price continued its descent. An array of stubborn obstacles marred the recovery, including an inherently flawed business model, the unceasing trend towards remote work, impending legal disputes, and crippling debts. The escalating pressures peaked in May 2023 with the sudden exit of CEO Sandeep Mathrani.

The Current Landscape and Influencing Factors

Stepping in as Interim CEO on May 26, David Tolley has yet to halt WeWork’s downward spiral. As of July 28, 2023, WeWork’s share price languished below a quarter, marking a devastating 97% decline since listing. Humiliatingly, the crisis has brought the company to the brink of being delisted from the NYSE.

Moreover, WeWork navigates a complex landscape, balancing substantial long-term lease obligations against crippling debt. The continued remote work trend complicates further as nationwide office vacancies remain significantly high. This paradoxical situation demands a profound reevaluation of what a sustainable business model in commercial real estate truly encompasses.

Charting WeWork’s Course: Three Potential Scenarios and Their Impact on the NYC Commercial Real Estate Market

WeWork’s future is a hot topic, teetering between three potential scenarios: bankruptcy, an acquisition by a rival, or securing additional funding. Each outcome paints a unique scenario for NYC’s commercial real estate landscape, affecting landlords, competitors, and investors. Let’s take a closer look.

The Bankruptcy Repercussion

A bankruptcy situation implies WeWork renegotiating its leases. Given WeWork’s dominant presence, this sudden shift can send shockwaves through the commercial real estate market, increasing inventory and dropping rent rates across the board. While tenants may celebrate, others wouldn’t. Here’s how:

  • Landlords: Many could face financial stress, as WeWork’s inability to pay rent would mean a massive loss of income. They may also have to deal with large, uniquely-designed spaces that could be challenging to lease without a major renovation.
  • Competitors: Companies like Regus, Knotel, and Spaces may encounter initial challenges due to the commercial real estate market dip and the skepticism around coworking spaces. However, they could end up absorbing WeWork’s clientele. Perhaps they could also lease the spaces WeWork vacates and operate them under their own brand.
  • Investors: WeWork’s bankruptcy would likely lead to substantial financial losses for investors. Equity investors risk losing their entire investment, while debt investors may only recuperate a fraction during bankruptcy proceedings.

Acquisition Aftermath

In an acquisition scenario, the impact would depend on the acquirer’s plan for WeWork’s leases. But, assuming a competitor takes over and continues operations in those locations, here are the potential implications:

  • Landlords: If the acquirer honors WeWork’s existing leases, landlords might sigh with relief. But there’s also a chance of renegotiations for lower rents or abandoning unprofitable locations.
  • Competitors: Acquiring WeWork could reduce competition in the coworking space market, potentially enabling the acquiring company to ramp up prices. Conversely, smaller competitors might seize the opportunity to grow by appealing to unhappy WeWork clients.
  • Investors: The return for investors would likely be less than their initial investment but certainly better than in the bankruptcy scenario. The exact impact would hinge on the specifics of the acquisition deal.

The Capital Infusion Scenario

If WeWork secures more funding, it could continue and potentially expand its operations. Such a scenario could have the following repercussions:

  • Landlords: If WeWork remains solvent and continues to pay rent, landlords would not only escape unscathed but could also enjoy increased market stability.
  • Competitors: With additional capital, WeWork could heighten coworking market competition by investing in expansion. However, this might also drive competitors to innovate and up their game.
  • Investors: Existing investors might see their stakes in WeWork diluted by a new round of funding. But, if WeWork reaches profitability, its long-term investment value could rise. For potential new investors, there would be significant risks and potential rewards.

The Key Takeaway

The 97% plunge in WeWork’s valuation is no small feat – it signals a company on shaky ground, with three possible routes ahead: bankruptcy, acquisition, or an uphill struggle to raise capital. Each path presents a different challenge for New York City’s commercial real estate market, pushing landlords, competitors, and investors into a period of uncertainty.

In the long term, WeWork’s precarious situation could reshape the city’s commercial real estate landscape. With millions of square feet of space hanging in the balance, the fate of WeWork is not just about one company but the health of the entire sector. As we wait for the next chapter in this corporate saga, one thing is clear: the ripples of WeWork’s turbulent journey will be felt far beyond its own walls.

 

Accessibility Tools